elves, hobbits, wizards AND orlando bloom?
how could i *not* pick it?? :)

Honestly, I don't like any :S not my type of movie... please don't hurt me :(

Robots, ewoks, jedi knights AND Harrison Ford. How could I not pick it?? :)

No contest. Darth Vadar could kick Sauron's ass any day.

Well said, Chel!

It's classic. Even the one made two years ago is classic.

I thought the battle was usually between Star Wars and Star Trek. Now THAT would be a harder decision.

Sorry, but it was my first love. I can't imagine what my life would have been like if I didn't have Star Wars.

I give you the definitive answer to the debate here:
link

Laser blasting spaceships vs dragons that may or may not have fire breath. No brainer.

Both wonderful epic stories of the battle between good and evil. But if I have to pick one, Star Wars is both serious and funny, both sexy and goofy -- Lucas plays on a broader range of emotions.

I really dont like star wars, i only liked the one with jaja binks lol
xXx

Neither..

I don't know which one two pick. I love them both.

But only Star Wars Episodes 4-6. If Episodes 1-3 are mandatorily included, then I've got to go with LotR.

I can't do it, if I try i'm pretty sure my head will explode

Very close one though, I love them both.

nothin has ever made me want tpo sit through ne of them lotr films and i can just about stand star wars o thats my choice!

both good, but LOTR wins. Although Lightsabers beat swords

star wars is the bomb!!! I cant believe ppl are pick LOTR over star wars!

easy pick, lotr destroys star wars!
star was sucks compared to lotr!!!!

i cant believe ppl are picking star wars over lotr it is the best movie of all time i agree with kurt82 star wars is nothing compared to lotr

Don't get me wrong. I absolutely adore Star Wars (The original 3 anyway) but Lord of the Rings has to beat it for me. While I grew up watching Star Wars, I grew up reading LOTR, and I always wanted to be an elf-warrior more than a jedi knight (ok, I'm the biggest nerd in the room).

I don't agree with anyone who says either of them sucks.

I just love Lord of the Rings, it is my favorite movie!!! I don't really like Star Wars.

Talking about the films, there's no contest. LotR already seems incredibly dated (particularly looking at SFX), and working as they were with a beloved series of books they were bound to get stuff wrong. You can argue about how much and to what extent they got it wrong, but they did get it wrong. I just re-watched the trilogy this past week, and by the end I was cringing at how badly they mangled the story. Star Wars began as the films, so there's no expectations other than the films to disappoint viewers.

Now, if we were talking about the books, there'd be no contest, either, but it would be the other way around.

Wow, I'm really suprised by your comment... When I first heard that they were making LOTR into a movie, I was kinda angry because there are so few movies that get translated well to the big screen. However, when I saw LOTR I was really suyprised and happy, I enjoyed the way it was adapted. And I can say that about a very few number of books to movie adaptations. I mean, the films could never be as good as the book, but yeah, I definitely enjoyed it.

BEST MOVIE EVER CREATED! The books are great too. ebathory I agree Jackson did a great job adapting the books to film. I was (am) very pleased.

This wasn't even a difficult decision. George Lucas has done nothing but disappoint me since he started the franchise.

I honestly hate Star Wars.

I love them both, but I have to go with Star Wars

my fav s-f movie vs my fav fantasy movie .............. I Hate you :P

I love Star Wars but I love The Lord of the Rings. How can I possibly choose between two loves. So torn.