What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One Tree Hill who is least important character?? (please be honest, don't pick the one your like less

107 fans picked:
Brooke
   57%
Peyton
   22%
Haley
   17%
Lucas
   3%
Nathan
   1%
 alessandra_28 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

19 comments

user photo
leyton_love picked Brooke:
I love Brooke, but i just think that she's not as invloved with the other characters as everyone else. Whereas if you took, say, Lucas away, just about everyone in the show would be affected. Brooke, although she has a great storyline, doesn't really have much to do with anyone. Sure, if you took her away, Lucas and Peyton and everyone else would be upset, but the entire storyline wouldn't have to change completely if she left the show. I just think she is less important to the over-all story than the other four mains.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
laughingGrl picked Brooke:
lucas and nathan are the main two no duh. brooke is important, but her storyline seems to interlock with only smaller characters or peyton if anyone at all. peyton is really important because her storyline goes with lucas, brooke, and haley really well. and haley goes with luke and nathan, and peyton with the music. so brooke has the least amount of people with her storyline.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
EclecticFan picked Peyton:
i honestly think peyton's story lines have been the least significant... and i do love hil but i think out of any of them she could be cut out the easiest
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
alessandra_28 picked Brooke:
electic fan how you can say something like that? Peyton is the main girl...cut her out would be the most stupid thing ever, like laughingGrl said, her stroyline goes with everyone!!
Brooke is least important one, she was only created because Peyton needed a best friend and its all her character is about.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
abs07 picked Brooke:
she really doesn't have any loose ends with anyone (except her mom, heh). she's single, and doesn't really have family around. she's lovable to her friends, but that's a far as it goes. Peyton and Luke have each other. If one or the other left, the show would be unbalanced. Those two (especially luke) have changed many lives for the better. Hales and Nate are married with a kid. They can't leave.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
1treehillfan picked Brooke:
I honestly think they are all important to the show but I picked Brooke because Nathan And Haley is a VERY important relationship in the show, And we need Haley around to knock some sense into the characters- And now that brucas is end game we need Peyton and Lucas around for leyton... so I think that Brooke isn't really needed as much as the others.
I mean, she was originally added to the show just to lighten up everything because everyone had a really heavy story line.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Angelika picked Brooke:
i think that if she left that wouldn't coz a problem..first of all she is single..of course she has her friends who adore her but she hasn't got any issues with anyone that would be left unsolved if she left!!well Luke is the main guy so if he left there would serious problem..Nathan and Haley have a family and would be really odd if someone left and Peyton has Luke and the whole Leyton love story plus i think Peyton is the main girl out of the 3!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
OTHbrowser picked Brooke:
it's weird in the credits brooke goes after dan... how weird. does it mean she's less important than HIM??? :O
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
gogokef picked Brooke:
I think that YES! Brooke is less important than Dan! Dan is Lucas's and Nathan's father! Because of him there was all the fighting between Nate and Luke,,he killed Keith something that changed many things and his story line has to do with Nathan,Lucas,Jamie,Deb and Haley (because of Jamie)! I think too that Brooke is the less important because Lucas&Nathan are the main two,,Haley is Nathan's wife and Lucas's BEST friend! Peyton has Lucas and Haley because of music,Mia is in the show because of Peyton..she has so much! Brooke is Peyton's best friend...and she adds fun in the show ..but It wouldn't make a dramatic change if she'd left!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
mizzfelisha picked Peyton:
every1 that pick brook is a leyton fan...WOW!!

but i think peyton is the least important 1 cuz her storyline is so boring and annoying

she cry 2 much
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Lola543 picked Haley:
I agree wit u mizzfelisha ... even though i picked Haley
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Broody_4_Cheery picked Nathan:
i picked nathan, because even though he is meant to be one of the two main characters he doesnt really seem that important, other than being related to people. he doesnt have many stand alone storylines and his personality doesnt add a huge difference to the show. lucas is by far the core character, the person who connects them all and keeps them connected, he has a strong history with everyone. Peyton is the dramatic factor, adds a tortured character and a sort of poetry to the show, dont know quiet how to explain it, brooke adds a lighter mood, people have complained about her humour lacking in sn 5 what would it be like if she was gone for good, that humour and lighter side is very important to the show, and haley, everyones friend, is the moral centre, the girl next door quality. the show still needs nathan but i dont think his character brings as much to it as the others, and there for isnt as important though they are ALL in important and that is why its the core 5 not 6 or 4.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SG1-090 picked Brooke:
She's lifts out the easiest - but believe me if i had the choice i would prefer to lose Haley!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pippaab picked Peyton:
well first, of course people would be really upset if luke and nate left! haley and nate have a kid, so their not going anywhere! between brooke and peyton, i think peyton.. i dont know why, it just seems to me that if she left i wouldnt really notice.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kathiria82 picked Brooke:
The show wouldn`t be the same without any of them except Brooke. I like her but she wasn`t even supposed to be in the show.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
gogokef picked Brooke:
mizzfelisha don't be ridiculous!
We don't pick Brooke b/c we love LP..YOU picked Peyton because you can't stop f*** blaming her for everything..and it's funny because Peyton is the main girl! So try to judge as If you did not hate her and see the truth! xD

Brooke was not even in the pilot! xDDD
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Jessica4695 picked Peyton:
SO I think Peyton now .. because .. you know.
Naley is naley they are awesome 2gether and alone <3
They have a gr8 story and I think without them everything would change .. so ...
Brooke is a gr8 friend and the hole Brooke : I want to become a baby- thing rocks .. and Lucas is ready to become a family , too !
Brooke is funny and when somebody feel sorry or just feel bad she try everything to make them happy (:
She grow up !!! But I think Lucas isn't so important anymore ,too !
'cause he never had a really story .. he never was somebody !
Good in s1 he was the first xDD
but not anymore .. it change ..
and Peyton isn't so important 'cause (Im sorry for P.S. fans)
she just cry .. she have just sad scenes .. and when she isn't there anymore .. I think o.k everybody would be sad .. but tey can Forget her .. don't hate me for saying this but I think .. u know Lucas has in .. hmm maybe 1 month a nother girl friend .. brooke and haley would be BF'S and Nathan ... he don't care so much .. so ...
I Pick Peyton .. pls don't hate me !!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
alessandra_28 picked Brooke:
^^ so the only important character for you is Brooke? and you want a Haley & Brooke show??
let me tell you, next season without Lucas and peyton will be worst and the show will get cancelled!! because without the 2 most important characters OTH is nothing.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
svety74 picked Brooke:
For me all are important. A show like OTH which is built on 5 core people can't survive without one [just look at OC without Marissa]. IMO Naley and Leyton are important for a reason. They are the couples of the show, the story revolves around two brothers and their families i.e Peyton and Haley.

My least favourite character is Nathan because his storylines revolves around basketball but he is a part of Naley. Brooke on the other hand, is a friend to everyone but doesn't have a family on OTH and her storylines are quiet distant from the rest like Sam, Angie, Julian & the stalker storyline are an extra to the show.
posted over a year ago.