answer this question

Ouran High School Host Club Question

In episode 5, was the girl that spoke to the Hitachiin twins in hte beggining Haruhi?

My friend's trying to convince me that was Haruhi.
So, was it?
-Izzy
 Kiras_Follower posted over a year ago
next question »

Ouran High School Host Club Answers

Nini97 said:
It was most sertanly NOT Haruhi. As you recall she is a commoner and, before she entered Ouran, had never met the twins. That little girl was only a girl that went to their school... nothing else. Besides, judging by how old they looked, that was around the time haruhi's mom died so it couldent have been her! =]
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That's right - I think the animators just made her look like Haruhi for sentimental reasons.
polandforever posted over a year ago
*
The show never said the flashback took place at a school. Besides they looked pretty young, they couldn't have been older than kindergarten age, I may be wrong but I don't think there is such thing as a private school for kindergarten and under. Even so, I'm pretty sure it was just a playground in the park.
Raven-Eyes posted 20 days ago
*
And how would the death of Haruhi's mom affect anything? As long as it wasn't on the day of the funeral I don't think it would prevent her from being around other kids - in fact she could have been trying to make friends to keep her from falling into depression. Actually the twins' refusal to play with her could have contributed to her serious nature - they didn't want to play with her so she insisted on doing the chores and shopping to keep her mind off of her mother's death (her dad already stated that she was too responsible/mature/independent for her age)
Raven-Eyes posted 20 days ago
uran_fangirl said:
i think it could possibly be her because her mom was a lawyer so they could have ben rich in the past thus them meeting in the snow. or maybe this scene was at a park not at school and thats how they use to meet or something (plus the girl did look like younger Haruhi) if so maybe Haruhi just didn't remember them?

select as best answer
i think it could possibly be her because her mom was a lawyer so they could have ben rich in the past thus them meeting in the snow. or maybe this scene was at a park not at school and thats how they use to meet or something (plus the girl did look like younger Haruhi) if so maybe Haruhi just didn't remember them?
posted over a year ago 
luinwen said:
no it wasn't, it was a girl from their school
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
kitmolly123 said:
I don't think it was.It was a girl that went to their school.Haruhi could easily figure out which twin is which and she couldn't figure out which twin was which.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
definitely right.. she's not haruhi..
Rhaeign posted over a year ago
*
It never said they were at school, and they didn't show the little girl's answer to the question - she could have actually guessed correctly and if not then maybe she learned from it and that's why she was able to tell them apart so quickly. Also they implied that it was her at the end of the episode - Haruhi walked away from the twins and it shifted to the flashback of the little hitachiin twins on that park bench then showed the present twins standing in front of the same bench watching Haruhi walking away. I believe that it was Haruhi and they just didn't realize she was the same person until that moment.
Raven-Eyes posted 20 days ago
I_Love_Crona said:
personaly i think it was her. if i remeber correctly, it looked like they were hiding the fact that she was right.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »