Sort by:  Recently Created | Most Popular

🔎Guy Ritchie won't return to direct Sherlock Holmes 3 The fans pick: oh noes! 😱 let's hope dexter fletcher doesn't ruin the film 100% 0%

🔎 Hey fellas! Sherlock Holmes 3 is in the works! Tied! 50% 50%

Vote for a New Club Banner The fans pick: A new banner Ended over a year ago 100%

Jared Harris or Andrew Scott? Which of those two Moriartys do you prefer? The fans pick: Jared Harris 100% 0%

Whom of my 2 fav. Sherlock Holmes characters (books & movies) do you like best? The fans pick: Dr. Watson 71% 29%

[I'm always there to copy] ➢ let's do some association! I say 'sherlock holmes', you think of... The fans pick: ☇ sir arthur conan doyle' books 40% 30%

what dose sherlock all ways say to watson The fans pick: its elimentry my dear watson its elimentry my dear watson 100% it sucks sir 0%

Have you seen Sherlock Holmes in the 22nd Century? The fans pick: No 85% 15%

Which one is the best Sherlock Holmes? The fans pick: No one, the book character has always been the best one 92% 4%

Which one is more thrilling??? The fans pick: the speckeled band? the speckeled band? 92% The read haired league? 8%

would you read a short murder story i'm writing? The fans pick: yes 89% 11%

Who is the best Sherlock Holmes??? The fans pick: Robert Downey Jr. 55% 45%

Sherlock or Watson? The fans pick: Sherlock Sherlock 79% Watson 21%

Who are the BEST Sherlock and Watson from modern times? The fans pick: Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman (BBC) 63% 38%

Would you watch another modern version of Sherlock Holmes, only this time set in the USA? The fans pick: No 45% 28%

Who's the better Holmes of recent times? The fans pick: Benedict Cumberbatch 57% 43%

What's the greatest Holmes short story? The fans pick: Silver Blaze Silver Blaze 31% The Red- Headed League 25%

Who is your favourite Holmes? The fans pick: Benedict Cumberbatch 32% 27%

Who is your Favourite Watson actor? The fans pick: Martin Freeman 38% 33%

Do you think that those two kids from The Little Rascals look kind of like younger versions of Holmes and Watson? The fans pick: No 64% 36%

Do you think there was somw kind of romantic connection between Holmes and Irene Adler? The fans pick: Yes 59% 41%

In canon, what color is Watson's hair? The fans pick: Brown Brown 43% It varies 29%

Do you think that Watson lied about being married? The fans pick: No, his wife (s) were not ficticious 100% 0%

Do you think Moriarty was never real and Holmes just imagined him or made him up? The fans pick: No, he was real 100% 0%

What actor do you think should play Professor Moriarty in another Sherlock Holmes movie? The fans pick: Christoph Waltz 21% 13%

What actor do you think should play Dr. John Watson in another Sherlock Holmes movie? The fans pick: Ewan McGregor 36% 29%

What actor would you like to see play Sherlock Holmes in another movie? The fans pick: Johnny Depp 35% 32%

Which is the best word to describe Sherlock Holmes? The fans pick: Genius Genius 67% Eccentric 19%

What's the best word to describe Dr. Watson? The fans pick: Loyal Loyal 52% Friend 30%

Do you think that Sherlock Holmes had Asbergers syndrome? The fans pick: No, I don't think so No, I don&# 39; t think so 65% Yes, I beleive he did 35%

Do you think David Tennant could have played Mycroft in the BBC series "Sherlock"? The fans pick: Maybe... 41% 23%

Have you watched the BBC series "Sherlock"? The fans pick: Yes, and I liked it! 83% 13%

Who do you prefer as narrator? The fans pick: Watson 81% 19%

do you like MRS HUDSON? (landlady of sherlock holmes) The fans pick: YES. she's affectionate and careful towards sherlock holmes 100% 0%

Which story? The fans pick: The Hound of the Baskervilles The Hound of the Baskerv- illes 80% The Red- Headed League 20%

Which character? The fans pick: Sherlock Holmes Sherlock Holmes 85% Dr. John Watson 15%

Who's better? The fans pick: Jeremy Brett Jeremy Brett 84% Basil Rathbone 16%

Michael Caine as Sherlock Holmes in a straight-film? The fans pick: No...sorry 65% 18%

What did you think of Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes in the series Sherlock? The fans pick: I thought he was amazing as Sherlock. 69% 17%

Favourite repeat offender :) (Pick your LEAST favourite Watson) The fans pick: Edward Hardwicke 50% 25%

Favourite repeat offender :) (Pick your LEAST favourite Holmes) The fans pick: Ian Richardson 100% 0%

Favourite repeat offender :) (Pick your LEAST favourite Watson) Tied! 25% 25%

Favourite repeat offender :) (Pick your LEAST favourite Holmes) The fans pick: Matt Frewer 50% 25%

Who's your favourite out of these one-time interpreters of Holmes? The fans pick: Nicholas Rowe (1985) 39% 17%

Would you like to met Arthur Conan Doyle? The fans pick: I would rather meet Sherlock Holmes! 70% 24%

Do You Think Jeremy Brett as Sherlock holmes is Hot? The fans pick: Yes!!! 83% 17%

Out of Conan Doyle's favourite stories, which do you like most? The fans pick: A Scandal in Bohemia 23% 21%

Do you like Adler The fans pick: Yes 53% 50/ 50 34%

Do you love scary films? The fans pick: YES 67% 33%

WHO IS BETTER? The fans pick: Sherlock Holmes Sherlock Holmes 89% Robert Downey jr 6%

Is there somekind a guide on Art of Deduction? I´d like to know how Sherlock Holmes and the Mentalist just know everything about anyone. The fans pick: Art of deduction Art of deduction 61% Art of deduction 17%

Edward Hardwicke or David Burke? The fans pick: Edward Hardwicke 55% 45%

What's your favorite Sherlock Holmes quote? The fans pick: When you've eliminated the impossible,whatever remains,however improbabl... 46% 15%

Who is the best detective the world has ever known? The fans pick: Sherlock Holmes 87% 6%

Which name do you prefer? The fans pick: Sherlock 63% 20%

Do you think Sherlock get along with Mycroft? The fans pick: Yes! 81% 19%

Holmes or Watson? The fans pick: Love them both!!! 58% 30%

Have you noticed the similarities between Sherlock Holmes and Gregory House (House MD)? The fans pick: Yes! I love House too! 73% 27%

Is Robert Downey Jr the right choice to play Sherlock Holmes? Tied! I think he could pull it off. 19% Hell NO! I want Hugh Laurie! 19%

This poll may contain spoilers. Click here to reveal the question.

Have you read any of Doyle's other works? The fans pick: No, I haven't. No, I haven&# 39; t. 56% Yes, and I like them too! 29%

Was Holmes addicted to drugs? The fans pick: Yes, it's an unfortunate part of his character. Yes, it&# 39; s an unfortunate part... 54% No, he just took drugs to... 17%

The Ultimate pick: Who is the best Holmes? The fans pick: Jeremy Brett 51% 15%

Do you find Holmesian fanfiction tedious, or do you read it? The fans pick: Have read it... Some are well written, others.. decidedly not. 40% 32%

Which is your favorite Sherlock Holmes novel? The fans pick: The Hound of the Baskervilles The Hound of the Baskerv- illes 58% A Study in Scarlet 28%

Have you read all of the original Sherlock Holmes stories (novels and short stories)? The fans pick: Yes 63% 37%