Silent Hill

answer this question

Silent Hill Question

Silent Hill 4: The Room, Joke or not?????

how many people consider this to be a joke compared to the other games? true there are a few good scares but apart from that it just made me laugh all the way through the game. the main character doesnt even go to silent hill i mean come on its like calling resident evil 5 a real resident evil game when its not, i know this is gonna start a flame war but its not.
 emo_grl_4eva posted over a year ago
next question »

Silent Hill Answers

Bond_Of_Fury said:
Silent Hill 4 a joke? No. It was easily the most CREEPY in the series. True, it isn't SCARY as Silent Hill 3 or the original, but but the fact that you never actually went out of the room, was really disturbing. Plus, have you seen Elle's head!?

The real joke in the series was Silent Hill 2, if you ask me.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeh ok i will admit SH 2 was a joke too but at least u went to silent hill
emo_grl_4eva posted over a year ago
*
Yes, that's true. But you could think of Silent Hill 4 as a game on its own that way, right?
Bond_Of_Fury posted over a year ago
*
in that case why hav the name silent hill on the from cover, just doesnt cut it for me in my opinion
emo_grl_4eva posted over a year ago
Red_Pyramid206 said:
Honestly, when I first played Silent Hill 4, I thought it was a joke. I hated it and thought the gameplay was dumb. But after a while I loved it. I love Building World so much. Plus, I think ALL the SH are good. Homecoming was great but it was too short and it needs downloadable content
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Pachi-kun said:
This question is a joke. The Room was actually the Silent Hill game that made me interested in the series, and I really can't call it a joke. It has a really unique story, unlike the later games, despite the fact that I love Homecoming.

Sure, it had some flaws, but it's not a joke. In my opinion, I actually find the second game to be more of a joke, because the story has been used so many times.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
honbear said:
Actually emo_grl_4eva , many people don't even count this as a Silent Hill game because of the fact that it doesn't have anything to do with the actual town. I myself own it but have never played it because of the faulty plot.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!