so...it seems as so that people tend to compare twilight charaters to Host charaters. To be quite honest i really really don't like this. Sure they are both from the same author but I really don't think that, that should give us a lisence to correspond every single charater. I think this because i believe that Meyer wanted to make all of her charaters speaical and different for each other in every one of her books. Sure some of the charaters are going to have origins that grow from others but some people don't like charaters just because they correspond to some charaters in twilight. and to be honest i think that is the reason why people hate on some host charaters. What I really don't like is how people compare Edward to Ian. I think that Ian is way nicer than Edward. Some people also compare jared to Jake which i think is a little absurd. Or Jake and ian which to me makes not that much sense. Anyway the point of my rant is don't jugde a host charater just cause they are something like your least or hated twilight charater.
By the way I LOVE them both!!