Critical Analysis of Twilight Club
Join
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
There are 5 things you need to know-

This article is basically:
1. My story on how I got sucked into the Twilight Universe.
2. My life story on how Twilight has changed me. A lot.
3. A rant on why I like and hate about the series.
4. A confession on why I can't seem to get over with hating and loving it.
5. An opinion about how my life could have been without Twilight.

WARNING: Overall, this article is about... why I think Twilight isn't that 'bad' after all. It's going to be lengthy. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

This had me wondering for a while and to be honest, I'm still perfectly puzzled with myself. We all know that the Twilight Series is horribly flawed and Stephenie Meyer does not deserve the praise that she has been receiving for a horrible series of books. (Well, not everyone...) I know it as well. That realization (finally!) hit me when I reread the books a few times. How long it has taken me to realize the books aren't as good as they seem makes me feel really silly. But what can you expect from a 14-15 year old girl who had no clue what romance or love is?

Phase 1:

Anyway, it was my best friend who recommended the books to me. When I started reading the series, I was completely hooked. A girl who falls in love with a vampire- forbidden love... "OMG. That was so ROMANTIC!", the ignorant me thought. It took me a day to finish the book and I went on with New Moon. After finishing New Moon in a single day, I was craving for more and I borrowed my friend's copy of Breaking Dawn... At that time, I thought Breaking Dawn wasn't too bad *facepalm*, I sighed at B&E's wedding and honeymoon, I pitied Jacob when reading his POV, I was annoyed with Bella who was angry with Jacob for imprinting on her daughter and I was so 'happy' that everyone got their 'happily ever after'. But honestly, I hated Bella ever since she became a vampire. (lol) After that, I got my copy of Eclipse. I couldn't wait for my friend to lend me her copy, so I bought one for myself. Anyway, I really enjoyed it. Later, I bought the whole series.

After reading the entire series, I guess you can say that I was in a Twilight daze. When I went grocery shopping and I saw this crate of apples, I thought of Twilight. When a red truck passed by me, I thought of Twilight. When I saw the name Edward in my Maths textbooks, I thought of Twilight. When I tripped over something, I thought of Twilight. Oh hell, everything I see or do, I could relate it to Twilight.

That was Phase 1. Now here comes Phase 2:

When I heard that they were making a movie on Twilight, I was so happy(!). I got really excited and I wanted to know more about it. So, I fired up my computer, which I only used for school assignments, and started searching around the WWW. At that time, my knowledge on computers was really basic. I didn't even know how to start an email account. All I knew was Youtube and Google. Oh, and not forgetting the old faithful Wikipedia, which has helped me with a lot of school projects. ;)

Back to the story... I started off by downloading fanart, photos and a whole lot of images of Twilight through Google images. From then onwards, I changed. In a good way and in a bad way. My computer skills improved A LOT. I found new websites, I learned how to use Photoshop by myself, I finally set up my very own email account and I was very proud of it. LOL. I went surfing around the net, updating myself on the Twilight movie AND I found... Fanpop!

It was through the Twilight Series spot where I found Fanpop. I watched videos after videos, answered picks and quizzes, browsed through the thousands of images and read articles after articles. That was how I got addicted with Fanpop and I became a really active contributor to the Twilight spot. Oh and I was Team Edward back then.

And here is Phase 3:

I was all prepared for the Twilight movie. I went out with a bunch of friends to watch the movie. well, I didn't exactly like the movie but I was contented, for the time being (I never liked Kristen's acting. Muahahaha). Although I didn't like the movie, I got a copy of the Twilight movie poster from an entertainment magazine that I subscribed to and stuck it on my wall with pride.

There was this interview of Robert Pattinson in the magazine. And they had a really pretty picture of Rob and Kristen (Remember- that was a really long, LONG time ago) and I just... fell in love with the picture. I cut it out and tried to sketch it out. And now, THIS was when I found out that I had a gift in art. I was no Leonardo Da Vinci but anyway, I was so pleased with myself, like: OMG! I can't believe I drew this!! I started doing a lot of sketches after that. Later, I started doing paintings too and took part in several competitions. I won in some and lost in some. =)

Hope I'm not boring you. Wait, I already am. Anyway, if you're still reading this, here's Phase 4:

Visiting Fanpop daily became a habit. I reread the books again and again and I wasn't tired of them. Rereading the books made me like Jacob even more. I understood him better. I've never hated him. Soon, I switched to Team Switzerland. Then... the New Moon movie. PERIOD. I was in full fangirl mode. Got involved in many Twilight fansites, especially newmoonmovie.org. I made a number of online friends and I finally graduated to Facebook. =D

A few months has passed and I was still stuck with the same old books. Soon, I saw the light and I got terribly bored with the Bella & Edward... thing. The more times I reread the books, the more I disliked Bella and Edward and I grew to like Jacob even more. And I started to have this funny feeling about Breaking Dawn.How did this happen? Now, here's my current opinion on Twilight.

1. I realized there was nothing romantic about Edward and Bella at all. Sure, Edward cared about Bella and was extremely protective of her and Bella was madly in love with him. But I began to question. How did they fell in love? What are those special qualities that they see in each other that made them willing to die for each other? The more I reread the books, the more I began to question. I was no longer 'attracted' to Edward. I thought that his so-I-thought romantic lines were like those from Hallmark cards. I began to really despise Bella. I was like: Why the hell didn't she do this...?? Or this...? What the f**k was she thinking?? I had multiple headdesk occasions.

2. I began to understand Jacob. I know a lot of people dislike him and I understand that. He has plenty of weak points and was an idiot in some occasions. That is what I like about him. He has flaws, just like the rest of us, which makes him more realistic. Otherwise, I thought he was a really nice guy. I mean- what kind of guy would actually allow himself to be some wimpy girl's crying shoulder and let himself be brokenhearted so many times by a girl whom he actually really cared for? (IMO, I don't think such a guy like Jacob in the world exist. Seriously. Meyer is really good at making me delusional. I SHALL NOT FALL UNDER YOUR SPELL, MEYER!!!)

3. Breaking Dawn. *barfs* At first, I was totally comfortable with Renesmee being with Jacob. Then, it all started to make sense. NOT. How is imprinting ever going to work out? How in the world is it possible for Bella to be pregnant with some dead guy's sperm? Why can't Jacob just fall in love like a normal guy? Why did he have to imprint on a BABY?? Meyer went against her own logic. If imprinting was supposed to make stronger wolves, why did Jacob imprint on Renesmee? If she was going to stop growing 7 years later, how the hell is she going to reproduce to make stronger wolves and BLAHBLAHBLAH?? It would have made more sense if he imprinted on some other Quileute girls but RENESMEE? Come on. And don't tell me that Jacob fell in love with Bella because of her... ovum.

Anyway, I still wasn't over Twilight but I was over Edward and Bella. And then... I found the Critical Analysis of Twilight(CAT) spot!

Until now, I'm still amazingly in love with this spot. ♥♥♥ I love reading the articles and other Fanpoppers' comments (especially the antis). And how could I have ignored all those funny images in the CAT spot? :D I enjoyed being part of the CAT spot and I still do.

How about now? Phase 5:

To be completely honest, I think I never fully got over Twilight. There are parts in it that I still enjoy but I'm no longer like: TWILIGHT IS THE BEST BOOK THAT I'VE EVER READ! I watched the movies (Twilight & New Moon) and I'm waiting to watch the next one- Eclipse.

And I'm sure that I'm still on Team Jacob and not an anti. I never was, although sometimes I may sound like one. Why I can't seem to get over it, like many other ex-Twilighters in the CAT spot, still remains a mystery to me. And like I've said earlier, I'm well aware that Twilight is a really overrated book. *coughs*

Well... MAYBE it's because I'm able to relate with some of the characters in the books. Or MAYBE it's because Twilight has brought me closer with my friends and family (Twilight sometimes comes into our conversations every now and then, and I actually find those conversations pretty entertaining). Or MAYBE it's because I think that if Twilight was done and ended my way (no stupid pregnancy, no stupid imprinting, no stupid Renesmee, etc), it could have been better. Or MAYBE it's because I'm still shipping Bella & Jacob, even though there is no chance at all for them to be together in the end anymore. (That's why I've turned to Fanfiction.net. Guilty pleasure. *shrugs*)

Or MAYBE... it's because I grew up with Twilight. I can't deny that Twilight has changed me a lot. If it wasn't for Twilight, I might/could have (been):

1.an idiot with computers.
2.living under a rock and not know how to set up my own email account.
3.not discovered that I had a thing for art and not took part in those art contests and won those prizes and made my parents proud.
4.not be able to differentiate between good literature materials with bad ones.
5.not discovered Fanpop and the CAT spot & met the many awesome people around here. =)
6.not realized that there is more to life than being irrevocably in love with a guy. Or in Twilight's case- a vampire...
7.not be as close with my friends and cousins as I am with them now.
8.not discovered the wonders of the WWW. There are other websites besides Wikipedia! Ooohhh...
9.not realized that love is not about exchanging romantic words with each other. Instead... love is just friendship on fire.
10. a very boring person. I think. =P

I guess what I'm trying to say is that behind every bad thing, event or even a book, there is bound to be something positive about it. Although Twilight isn't a really good book, which sends out the a lot of wrong messages to young girls out there, I have to admit that I have learned a lot from it. It's funny how Twilight has brought a lot of changes in my life, and IMO, most of them are positive ones too.


~rachaelwsz

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oh wow. This is... my longest essay/article. Ever. My English teacher will be very proud of me... but not with my grammatical errors. I hope you don't mind the rant. I badly needed a good, long rant. =P
"Hey! Maybe Twilight isn't that bad after all!"
"Hey! Maybe Twilight isn't that bad after all!"
I drew this back when I was in my Twilight fangirl mode. I actually haven't fully completed it yet because I'm too lazy. lol.  (Date: 13th August 2009)
I drew this back when I was in my Twilight fangirl mode. I actually haven't fully completed it yet because I'm too lazy. lol. (Date: 13th August 2009)
actually she just specified on Nuttymadam's "genius" claim
video
video
twilight
eclipse
movie
parody
3shadeproductions
added by McDreamyluva
video
funny
criticism
craig ferguson
vampires
twilight
edward cullen
Mike Nelson, Kevin Murphy and Bill Corbett riffing the film New Moon.
video
twilight
funny
edward cullen
bella swan
stephenie meyer
jacob black
added by walker93
Vampires from all over meet for their annual reunion. Appearances by Edward Cullen, Angel, Dracula, Count von Count, Bill Compton, and more. Featuring a special visit from Buffy.
video
vampires
spoof
edward cullen
angel
dracula
count von count
bill compton
buffy
Hahahahahaha... Team Flea @1:40 LOL. xD
video
parody
funny
spoof
puppet
twilight
new moon
edward cullen
bella swan
Watch that part at 1:50-3:10. Taylor did mentioned it before in another interview a few months back. The 40+ year old woman asked him to sign her Team Taylor panties during some autograph session... O_O I thought it was creepy...
video
twilight
new moon
taylor lautner
twimum
fan encounter
shocking
interview
jay leno
I recently got into the show Supernatural (everyone should), and I happened upon this hilarious video. It shows how Dean Winchester (My new favorite character of all time) is better than Twilight.
video
twilight
funny
parody
edward cullen
bella swan
stephenie meyer
supernatural
dean winchester
Someone doesn't like what Edward Cullen and his Twilight pals are doing to Vampire Mythology. Another funny parody. :)
video
twilight
funny
edward cullen
bella swan
A video on how I was convinced of Twilight's problematic nature.
video
twilight
problematic
feminism
sexuality
video
twilight
funny
critical analysis
rant
itskingsleybitch
added by walker93
Another EvilIguanaProduction Twilight related parody, this time on one of the New Moon trailers.
video
parody
spoof
eviliguanaproduction
funny
new moon
trailer
5:20 I wonder what some of the fans think of this. I think Taylor has noticed that some fans don't like him simply because he plays Jacob so is saying he's not on any teams when he's made it clear he's Team Jacob. Poor Tay.
video
robert pattinson
edward cullen
team jacob
interview
So I was originally going to publish this article in the Books to Read spot, but then found this place, and I think it fits in here much better :) Anywho, this is an opinion article I originally wrote for my school newspaper. Yes, it's a bit of a rant, but I don't mean to be offensive, so please don't take it that way. Enjoy :)

--------------------------

There’s no way you haven’t heard of it. From the first publishing of that first book to the most recent perfume-bottle scandal, Twilight has permeated the very core of pop culture, not to mention high school conversation. No matter whether...
continue reading...
Fromthisgirl on YouTube has a question for the Twilight fangirls. She also explains why she thinks they AREN'T in love.
video
twilight
love
stalker
vampires
criticism
fromthisgirl
added by Bluelunacy7
added by katiecain
Source: http://lucylou.livejournal.com
The sequal. Oh. "I almost don't wanna watch it. SO that I can you know, watch it again later?"
video
twilight
funny
trailer
reaction
added by Cinders
Source: clairebear12 @ deviantART
added by nuxi
Source: Tonight Show