One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 1410

over a year ago OTH_1988_fan said…
Nathan

Haley or Peyton?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
oihhh love em both both gotta say peyton

Season 1 or season 3?
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Season 3

Clay or Quinn?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
zzz
Clay.

Phsyco Derek (Ian) or Crazie Nannie Carrie
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Physco Derek

Deb or Karen?
over a year ago Naleyluv23 said…
Deb

Keith or Dan????
over a year ago thingofoth2009 said…
smile
hi guys im new at this and im just asking is there going be a season 8 or not and when das it come out
and i like hayily
over a year ago cissy121 said…
Keith!

Jamie or Sawyer
over a year ago Seddie4Ever said…
Sawyer

Season 2 or Season 5?
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Season 5

Larry or Mick?
over a year ago KezzF18 said…
Mick.

Chris Keller or Tim Smith?
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Tim Smith

Good Dan or Evil Dan?
over a year ago NicoleBanksxx said…
smile
i like hayley
over a year ago xoheartinohioxo said…
Evil Dan!

Brooke's clothing line OR Haley's singing career.
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Both but Haleys singing career


Unkindness of ravens or The comet
over a year ago xoheartinohioxo said…
Unkindness of Ravens.

Lucas/Lindsay or Peyton/Julian
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Lucas/linsay


High school Brooke or Older Brooke
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
aaawww that's hard I love both but think il go with
High school Brooke

3.16 (school shootnig) or 6.17 (peyton could lose baby, Julian says he love Brooke ect)
over a year ago Amy-x said…
3.16

1.01 or 7x.01
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
7.01

Julian or Lucas (with brooke)
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Lucas.

3.09 (82 letters episode) or 3.13 (Blackout episode)
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
3.13

High school Brookes high or mature brookes hair?
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Mature Brooke

Senior year or Junior year?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
senior year

naley rain kiss or brucas rain kiss ?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
naley rain kiss
Hmmm... Anne or Lindsey?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Lindsey...

Breyton or Laley?
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Laley

Baley or Clathan?
over a year ago kellyclarkson12 said…
Clathan.
Quinn or Taylor??
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
Quinn

Jake or Lucas?
over a year ago laughingGrl said…
rivercourt or karen's cafe/cob
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Lucas

Cooper or Keith?
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Keith

Lindsay's wedding dress or Peyton's wedding dress
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
RiverCourt /// Peyton's Wedding dress

Brooke or Peyton's hair?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Peytons Hair.

Anna or felix?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Felix.

Nathan with shaved hair(season 3) or Nathan with long hair(season 4)?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
nathan with shaved hair

mouth or skills ?
over a year ago Amy-x said…
Mouth, though i love them both.

Nikki or Jules?
over a year ago J-C said…
Nikki!

Rachel or Chris?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Rachel.

Rivercourt or the Ravens` gym?
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
RiverCourt...although i love the gym too.

Peyton season 3 or Peyton season 6?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Peyton Season 6...

Haley the rockstar or Haley the tutor girl?
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
mischievous
Haley the tutor girl...omgg i love both! I want to kill you kry =P

Nathan playing Basketball or Slamball?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Basketball...duhhh :P

Jamie and Andre or Nathan and Chase (in the kareoke episode)
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
Nathan and Chase ♥

Brooke taking care of Angie or Sam?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Damn...Brooke taking care of Sam. This was really hard to choose. I`m gonna kill you tomorrow for making me choose this S :P

Brooke's hair in season 5 or Haley's hair in season 1?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
kiss
Soooo easyyyy! Brooke's hair in season 5! ♥

The group going to honey grove or Nathan, Skills and Mouth stripping in season 4?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
mischievous
The group going to Honey Grove (:

Okay I`m making it harder then...Brooke`s dimples or Peyton`s legs? :P
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
kiss
arghhhhhh!!!

Why are you making me choose this...=(

Peyton's legs

---------

Nathan's hot body or Lucas's hair and face in this pic?
arghhhhhh!!! Why are you making me choose this...=( Peyton's legs --------- Nathan's hot body or
over a year ago BellaBrooke said…
cool
Nathan's body!!!!!!
Brooke's fashionline or peyton's label?
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
Hard...but Peyton's label..I love music more =)

Girls night in season 2 or in season 7?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!