Robert Pattinson Article: twilight the movie? or the book?

5

posted by shannon0316

I read twilight and saw the movie but for someone out there that didn't read or see twilight or just read a little of twilight and can't decide what to do, i'm here for you. The book and the movie are both very good. But my opinion, the book was better. So much more descriptive, more feeling. The movie is also good. I'd give it 2 and a half stars in the paper. It was good because you could actually see what was going on. You can hear them talking but you can also hear the words perfectly spoken if you listen to the book. What I did was I read the book and then saw the movie. It was great because you knew the story and it was like the story jumped out of the book and onto the screen. ALMOST! Some of the greatest parts of the book weren't in the movie!

Xandragirl, joan_vrX and 3 others like this

AliceHaleCullen I completely agree with you. The movie brings the book alive and makes you properely visualise the books without little or any effort. But the books always win in my opinion because you can visualise what you want everything to look like & sound without limitations. In a movie, there are always limitations with how something can or cannot be made, like the running for example. They can't make the actors/actresses seriously run 100mph because it would be waaaay to dangerous and risky.

Hollieberry The book is ALWAYS better. HOWEVER, in this one rare case...I saw the movie before I read the book and I liked that. For one reason only....as I read the book, which was SO much better....I could picture Robert Pattinson's gorgeous face in each and everything Edward did. *sigh* It was nice to have a face (an incredibly handsome face) to go with the character (and...probably the most romantic and dreamy character ever imagined I will add...)

cherry101 hollieberry? you are appsolutly right i love edwart hes hot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:)