answer this question

Debate Question

Can someone explain nihilism more clearly?

Okay, What is the logic behind nihilistic view? How can someone deny the existence of good and bad? I don't get it...
 Nick16 posted over a year ago
next question »

Debate Answers

whiteflame55 said:
Well, most nihilists are of the existential variety, meaning that they argue that there is no intrinsic value or meaning to life. The view is that there is no deity that created life, and therefore life is the result of happenstance and thus lacks any meaningful purpose.

But what you're talking about is moral nihilism. It's actually pretty logical - morality is a construct that we humans built to control our fellows, and it does not inherently exist. There is no objective morality because what someone views as moral is often not shared by another random person. Morality, thus, is entirely subjective, and therefore the idea that something is "good" or "bad" is also entirely subjective. So long as we agree that morality is subjective, nihilism makes a good deal of sense, since it's not so much a denial of good and bad, but rather a denial of an objective good or bad.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
So, if I believe morality is subjective, does that make me a nihilist?
Nick16 posted over a year ago
*
Not necessarily. You can still believe there is a good and bad, just that those things aren't necessarily going to be shared views. You could hold that there is a single or even a small group of objective morals (say, utilitarian views) and thereby have a standard that defies nihilism as well. One of the strongest responses to nihilism, however, is to embrace subjectivity rather than spurn it. You accept that good and bad may not be obvious, and make an attempt to understand other points of view and embrace our differences on this and other subjects rather than spurning it altogether.
whiteflame55 posted over a year ago
next question »