Way back in Season 2 Episode... errrgghh.... 7, the tailies fell upon The Arrow Station witch looked like a storage facility. While looking through the stuff, Libby found a glass eye...and then it was never seen or talked about again...so who's was it?




The 3 Prime suspects:

1. Mikhail - We first saw this fellow In Season 3 Episode 5 'The Cost Of Living *sniff* Eko *sniff*...I thought this was the creepiest guy ever on LOST with his eye patch...followed by Ben ofcourse, but it might not be his eye as in the season 3 finale you saw what was under his eye patch and the eye lid was stuck shut (Can't explain it more than that!!)...but I could be wrong. SO....How could fit the glass eye in his socket?



2. Mr Paik - This is the TheMisFit's prime suspect...Here is what he has to say:
'I have RECENTLY discovered that the GLASS eye that the TAIL people found in the SPARROW hatch/bunker ACTUALY belongs to to SUNS father Mr. PIKE!! I think THIS lays to rest another of LOSTS many mysteries!! There iS no need to THANK me!!'
link



3. Jacob - If you freez frame or slow down the meeting with Jacob you can see that creepy person in physical form, but only for a split second but you do see someone's eye...and it wasn't Locke's or Ben's! See for your self...does it look like a glass eye?