Good Deeds x 2 + Pity Points - Evil Deeds = V
Here’s how it works:
Step 1 -
I made a list of all the reasons a villain should be hated as well as the reasons they should be liked and pitied.
The Evil Deeds are measured on a scale of 1-5 with 5 being most evil (i.e. killing someone) and 1 being least evil (i.e. lying)*
The Good Deeds are measured on a scale of 1-5 with 5 being most good (i.e. Saving a life) and 1 being least good (i.e. showing remorse)*
*If a large amount of people were involved double it.
The Pity points are measured on a scale of 1-5 with 5 being most tragic (i.e. unhappy childhood) and 1 being least tragic (i.e. lost something they liked)
Love Rules (it has its own rules):
Breaking a heart = 10
Unconditional love = 10
Showing love = 5
Losing a love = 10
Not being loved by someone they love = 10
Step 2 -
We all know that when something awful happens to someone we like it feels worse then if it happens to someone we don't like. So, when someone is wronged/assisted their likability is measured on a scale of 1-5 with 5 being most likable 3 neutral and 1 being least likable and added to the score.*
This means that lying to Belle (1+5x2= 12) can be just as evil as killing Milah (5+1x2= 12)
*If they wrong a person that they love double it.
Example -
Killed her father = 5+4x2 = 18
Regina kills her father - (1) murder is a 5 on the evil scale (2) add Henry's likability which is around 4 (3) and then double that number becaus she loved him. = 18
Rumple Rules:
Subtract 1 for every evil deed he does as the Dark One.
Any deeds (good or bad) that he does as part of a bargain is disqualified.
REGINA
---------------------------------------------
Bad Deeds
Enacted the curse = 3x2= 6
Killed her father = 5+4x2 = 18
Enslaves Graham = 5+5= 10
Kills Graham = 5+5x2= 20
Sends a whole bunch of children to their deaths = 5+3x2= 16
Breaks Genies heart = 10+2= 12
Kills king Leopold = 5+5= 10
Breaks Rumple’s heart = 10+5= 15
Imprisons Belle = 3+5= 8
Frames Snow/MM = 3+4= 7
Abandons Jefferson in Wonderland = 4+5= 9
Poisons Snow = 4+4= 8
Imprisons Charming = 3+2= 5
Attempts to poison Emma = 4+4= 8
Turns on her mother = 2-1=3
Uses magic on Henry = 2-4x2= 12
Kills a random woman = 5-2= 7
Attempts to kill her mother = 4+1=5
No concern for the lives of her guards = 3+2=5
Shows no remorse for her evil deeds = 2x2= 4
Tries to kill Snow = 4+4=8
Total = 196
Good Deeds
Shows remorse/love for her father = 1+4= 5
Loves Henry unconditionally = 10+4=14
Is kind to Kathryn = 3+2= 5
Tries to make her son happy = 3+4= 7
Shows remorse/love for Graham = 1+5= 6
Offers Hazel and Gretel a home = 3+3= 6
Shows remorse/love for Genie = 1+1= 2
Loves Daniel unconditionally = 10+3= 13
Saved Snow = 5+4= 9
Was kind to Snow = 3+4= 7
Does was is best for Henry = 4+4= 8
Swears of magic/evil deeds = 10
Shows remorse for the people her mother killed = 1+2= 3
Assists the good guys = 4+4= 8
Shows remorse/love for her mother = 1+1= 2
Saves Emma & Snow = 5+5= 10
Total = 115
Pity Points
Her son does not love her = 10
Her husband did not love her = 5
Had an unhappy childhood/abusive mother = 5
Betrayed by someone she trusted = 3
Lost her love = 10
Was forced to marry a man she did not love = 4
Is rejected by those she pursues = 2
Loses the last keepsake of her love = 3
Almost loses her son = 4
Loses her son = 10
The village turns against her = 3
Was used/manipulated by Rumple = 3
Loses her love again = 10
Loses her love yet again = 10
Her good deeds go unnoticed = 3
Is falsely accused = 3
Total = 88
GOLD/RUMPLE
----------------------------------------------------
Bad Deeds
Kills Cindy's fairy godmother = 5+2= 7
Transforms Gepetto's parents into puppets = 5+2= 7
Kills a whole bunch of people to protect his son = 5+1= 6
Was emotionally abusive to Belle = 4+5x2= 18
Beats Belles father within an inch of his life = 4+1= 5
Kills an innocent bystander = 5+2= 7
Kills a mute girl = 5+3= 8
Manipulates Emma & Regina for his own gain = 2+5= 7
Tries to kill Regina = 4+5= 9
Lies to Belle = 1+5x2= 12
Kills Milah = 5+1x2= 12
Breaks Hook's heart = 10+5= 15
Breaks Regina's heart = 10+5= 15
Used Regina as a puppet in his evil plan = 4+5= 9
Almost kills Emma & Snow = 4+5=9
Turns Smee into a rat = 3+4= 7
Beats Hook within an inch of his life = 4+5= 8
Rumple Rule = -11
Total = 113
Good Deeds
Loves his son unconditionally = 10+5= 15
Showed kindness/love for Belle = 5+5= 10
Ends war/saves a bunch of children's lives = 5+3x2= 16
Loves Belle unconditionally = 10+5=15
Saves Belle = 5+5=10
Loves his wife unconditionally = 10+1= 11
Tries to make Belle happy = 3+5= 8
Promises to become a better man = 10
Assists the good guys = 4+5= 9
Doesn't kill Hook = 1+5= 6
Total = 83
Pity Points
Lived an unhappy life of poverty = 5
Was hated by all as a coward = 10
Lost his love Belle = 10
Lost his Son = 10
Was Manipulated by August = 3
His wife left him = 10
Raised his kid alone = 5
Loses Belle again = 10
Total = 63
CORA
-----------------------------------
Bad Deeds
Abusive Parent = 4-5x2= 18
Kills Daniel = 5+4= 9
Breaks Regina's heart = 10+5x2= 30
Manipulates Regina for her own gain = 3+5x2= 16
Kills Lancelot = 5+3= 8
Massacres the refugees = 5+2x2= 14
Raises an army of the dead = 5x2= 10
Kidnaps/manipulates Aurora = 3+4= 7
Frames her daughter for murder = 4+5x2=18
Kills an innocent bystander = 5+3= 7
Kidnaps Archie = 4+4= 8
Total = 145
Good Deeds
Shows remorse/love for Regina = 5+5= 10
Total = 10
Pity Points
Betrayed by Regina = 2
Total = 2
HOOK
----------------------------------------------------
Bad Deeds
Steals Rumples wife = 3+5= 8
Humiliates Rumple = 4+5= 9
Assists Cora in evil deeds = 5x2= 10
Manipulates Aurora = 3+4= 7
Betrays Emma = 2+4x2= 12
Hits Belle = 4+5= 9
Threatens Archie = 3+4= 5
Shoots Bell = 5+5= 10
Total = 55
Good Deeds
Loved Milah unconditionally = 10+1= 11
Assists Band of Princesses in good deeds = 5+5= 10
Showed kindness/love for Emma = 5+4= 9
Returns Aurora's heart = 5+4= 9
Total = 39
Pity Points
Lost the woman he loved = 10
Betrayed by Emma = 10
Beaten with in an inch of his life by Rumple = 5
Total = 20
JEFFERSON
------------------------------------------
Bad Deeds
Kidnaps Snow & Emma = 4+5= 9
Assists Regina in evil deeds = 5x2= 10
Assists Rumple in evil deeds = 5x2= 10
Breaks Regina's heart = 10+5= 15
Total = 44
Good Deeds
Loves his daughter unconditionally = 10+4= 15
Tries to make his daughter happy = 4+4= 8
Frees Belle = 5+5= 10
Total = 33
Pity Points
Betrayed by Regina = 5
Lost his daughter = 10
Driven crazy by the Queen of hearts = 5
Driven crazy by Regina = 5
Betrayed again by Regina = 5
Total= 30
------------------------------------------------
To find the villains likability number use this equation:
Good Deeds x 2 + Pity Points - Evil Deeds = V
Here’s how it works:
Everyone knows that one good deed is worth two bad deeds when it comes to our villains so double the good deeds total.
Then add the pity points and subtract the evil deeds.
The villain with the lowest number is the most horrible unforgivably evil human being.
The higher the number the more admirable/relatable the person and they should be worshiped for they can do no wrong.
----------------------------------------------------
They've enjoyed their place on a pedestal for along time now but lets award it to them officially...
...
minervadawn is proud to present ...
The Once Upon a Time - Best Villain Ranking
1st place - Rumple with 127 points
2nd place - Regina with 122 points
3rd place - Jefferson with 52 points*
4th place - Hook with 33 points*
5th place - Cora with -123 points
*This equation does not account for the sexiness factor
If you’d like to do the math yourself go ahead. There is no black and white just many shades of gray. Where do the OUAT villain end up on you ranking?
Edit: I added in the events of 'The Outsider' and that sent Rumple's score from 96 up to 127 placing him just 5 points above Regina (It's really neck and neck in the Gina/Rumple smackdown now). Hook also went down 10 points from 43.
