OMGOMGOMG YOU MUST I SAY MUSTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!! WATCH Uragiri wa Boku no Namae wo Shitteiru (Betrayal Knows my name) it is much like Vampire Knight in that is it dark and supernatural and stuff. I LOVE IT SOOO SOOO SOO MUCH it is so damn good i like it as much as Vampire Knight. you must watch
with cute people? Not. The main girls in anime tend always to be pretty as u know it, and same goes with the males. But in vampire knight is different. Their boys have lines on face like girls. To be accurate their face is as beautiful as girls. That kind of beauty in anime world is Bishōnen. U can check out at Wikipedia...
The ones that also have pretty faces in anime are:
Shugo Chara (seen the pics not anime)
Princess Lover (currently watching this, still airing)
Wolf's rain (interesting animation for guys, great story)
Hope I helped bcs I am not into that Bishōnen anime...
Maybe you should watch K-ON!, it's very cute.
Rozen Maiden is an awesome anime too, you absolutely won't regret watching it, and Ouran is a must watch of course :P.
Also I recommend Clannad, Kaichou wa Maid-Sama, Chobits, the Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, Karin and a lot of other things ( ^ - ^ )
The picture is from Haruhi :D
Try Fortune Arterial. It's like Vampire Knight only it has more cuteness and less mystery.
Fortune Arterial's story revolves around the male protagonist Kohei Hasekura, who transfers into a prestigious public school in the style of an English six-year school encompassing junior-high and high school students. The school, named Shuchikan Academy, is on an island named Tamatsu Island off-shore from mainland Japan, and the only way to get there is by boat. Soon after transferring, he discovers that one of the students in the class next door to his, Erika Sendo, is in fact a type of vampire.
from borns the animations producers of full metal alchemist,eureka seven and cowboy bebop comes a brand new anime filled with mind-blowing action mysterious magic and a quest for the ultimate prize soul eater.from the original stories realized the comic magazine showningangan published by square-enix soul eater takes place in death weapon meister academy vocational school where children train with others as meisters and weapons all the students have the common goal on becoming death's death scythe to do so they have to collect 99 evil soul possessing a egg and the soul of a witch sometimes they fight each-other but they even help each-other but they never loose sight of they're goal the full metal alchemist makers makes soul eater come alive with long-lasting character and a different style of its own soul eater your soul is gonna be mine !
If you only wanna cute people try some yaoi stuff, like -Princess Princess(Only 1 gay kiss)
-OHSHC(the twins act to be gay)
-No.6(I'm still cursing, but there was only 1 kiss)
Then there are aslo all the animes/movies from studio Ghibli
-Howl's moving castle
I'm not sure, but Naruto guys are also cute.....
Oh, and Hell girl-Ren is HOOOOOOOT
Wolf's rain and Heart No Kuni No Alice(Rocks)
I haven't seen special a, but 'shinigami no ballad' is one that I would call the same genre... if you're more interested in the rival-danger-romance that's in vampire knight, you might want to try 'bajarou no kiss', and if you don't mind reading manga instead of watching anime, you should definetely try 'bloody kiss' (short serie) , it's also about vampires, and I haven't met a single person who didn't adore that serie as well as vampire knight ^.^