Girls Generation/SNSD Article: My opinion about Mr Mr (Overall)

1

posted by princess89

First of all, I am sorry if I am hurting any of you with my opinion. But this is what exactly I feel, when I listen to this song and watch the MV

Lines distribution
I know many people agree with me on this. I think the distributions are slightly unfair, even i am glad to hear Hyoyeon and Sooyoung more in this song. BUT Tiffany got so many lines. Even the high notes, while Seohyun only gets few lines. Honeslty, I think Tiffany is very bad during live performance. So I am very worried about that. But I guess it is too early to expect anything.

MV
Hurm, I don't have anything to say, because the MV is such a mess!!

Members
All of them looks very beautiful. Finally I get to see Sunny with long hair :) Miss that.

Music
Well, I like that. It becomes addicting. Even I actually expect more from them, but i am not disappointed.

Angelbell69 likes this

pearlxashxdawn I totally agree with you of the lines distribution. It really made me feel that SM thinks Tiffany is better than Jessica in singing (which for me is not true). Also agree with the MV. It was such a mess but all of them looked beautiful anyway (especially Tiffany, Jessica and Sunny). For me the music was eh okay. It wasn't addicting like IGAB but it was okay

nacchiee [i]I absolutely agree with most of your opinion. the lines distribution. well, I don't really mind that Tiffany got many lines. BUT I think she shouldn't have do the high note part. no offense , I really love her voice but only low-pitched voice not the high-pitched one/scream >< and imo Jessica or Seohyun would do it better. :D btw, I really loved Sooyoung's part in the bridge. <3 the MV, well maybe it was a bit mess, but I still liked it. I see it has a storyline/meaning.so interesting ! and the girls were really awesome. They looked beautiful, cool, sexy and handsome in just one MV. also SNSD doesn't really need to show much skin to look sexy, that's what I loved most. :D then for the music, actually I'm not disappointed at all, maybe I was expecting more but I still liked it, really. actually for me the song is nice and catchy but yeah I admit the first time I heard it I feel little bit boring but it became very addicting the more I heard. [/i] sorry If I wrote too much xD

Aya_tz the lines - Sure Tiffany and Taeyeon got alot of lines and they should give some lines to Yoona and Yuri. Maybe Hyo could give some too. the MV - it was not a total mess, sure its one of their worst videos but i did like some parts of it the music - I did expect more but the song made it in my to 10 so i likeit. Also i did like the whole album exept maybe Soul

Gretulee Well no offense, but I hate Taeyeon high lines when they sing all of them, I mean SNSD songs, not only Tae's,well I know all of you won't agree with me, and show me videos where Tae sing very well, but in these videos she sings alone, and it's ballads, thats what she sings very well, I hate Tae's high note's of SNSD songs, she can't normally sing them live...sorry...the best high notes are by Jessica...Tiffany singing normally, not impressive but same as MV...

Tippany First of all they distributed lines themselves. Second you guys shouldn't judge her like that, we don't know if she's going to improve or not. Third in other songs in the album, Taeyeon and Jessica got more parts.

princess89 agree with Gretulee. the best high notes are by Jessica. I don't like Tiffany high notes. Its kind of strain.. I actually miss Seohyun high notes like in The Boys...

Phuongphan I agree with you! I do feel like SM is Tiffany-biased. SOme people are saying TIffany is the 2nd best singer but she isn't. She's the fourth best singer but acts like the 2nd and sometimes the 1st