Firstable,
i am talking about the writers.
Be Objective, who writes her saga's the best?
ok, in my opinion, J.K. Rowling is way better writer than Meyer.
Why?
ok, #1 J.K. Rowling has written 10 books.
#2 she uses a more complex vocabulary and she creates a new one. with all the spells, names and a whole world of magic.
#3 the history she has to create year by year, has a really good continuity.
#4 Harry Potter characters have political and social foundations.
#5 the characters have to grow with the history and she make it look simple.
#6 she takes the risk of killing important characters, like Dumbledore, Dobby, Lupin, Tonks, etc. she does the unexpected thing.
well then Meyer has some points to her favor to:
#1 she make us feel like we are Bella.
#2 she transmitted all her feelings very well.
#3 she changes the idea of the traditional vampire. (her vampire sparkles)
#4 she is original on her way.
#5 she makes it appear like a diary, that is cool too.
So i just want to know your very own opinion...
i am fan of both, so i just want your opinion, putting outside who you like the best.
Comment whatever you want, just try to be honest with yourself and don't compare the books because they have nothing to do with.
P.S. Guys if i am wrong in something, please correct me! English is not my first language.
i am talking about the writers.
Be Objective, who writes her saga's the best?
ok, in my opinion, J.K. Rowling is way better writer than Meyer.
Why?
ok, #1 J.K. Rowling has written 10 books.
#2 she uses a more complex vocabulary and she creates a new one. with all the spells, names and a whole world of magic.
#3 the history she has to create year by year, has a really good continuity.
#4 Harry Potter characters have political and social foundations.
#5 the characters have to grow with the history and she make it look simple.
#6 she takes the risk of killing important characters, like Dumbledore, Dobby, Lupin, Tonks, etc. she does the unexpected thing.
well then Meyer has some points to her favor to:
#1 she make us feel like we are Bella.
#2 she transmitted all her feelings very well.
#3 she changes the idea of the traditional vampire. (her vampire sparkles)
#4 she is original on her way.
#5 she makes it appear like a diary, that is cool too.
So i just want to know your very own opinion...
i am fan of both, so i just want your opinion, putting outside who you like the best.
Comment whatever you want, just try to be honest with yourself and don't compare the books because they have nothing to do with.
P.S. Guys if i am wrong in something, please correct me! English is not my first language.
